Last year, when I reviewed PES 08, I mentioned that FIFA wasn't in the same league as PES, explaining "People don't play FIFA because it's the superior soccer game; they play it because it's got all the teams and players' people love, straight out of the box”. Although I only jumped on the PES bandwagon 3 years ago, I can see that PES has consistently been the better soccer game. Some mates and I still play PES 08 on a weekly basis (albeit on a far inferior console) whereas my copy of FIFA 08 actually has a fine layer of dust on it.

But when people rest on their laurels, as Konami has done a little with the last few PES games, a competitor can get the edge. And when that competitor is EA, the biggest publisher in the world, it gets very, very interesting. Because, if Konami don't address the issues of that last couple of PES games, then I think FIFA will be the better game this year.

First thing you'll notice is the fluid and organic player animation. Beautifully rendered, you'll see them flow naturally from one move to the next as they move down the pitch. This is true of the overhead cams, and the closer third person perspective of be-a-pro mode. It's also functional – you'll notice a tired player leaning over with hands on knees. A player wanting a pass will throw their hand up. And a scoring player can now be made, manually, to do those crazy soccer celebratory moves like the robot and belly slide.

This year the A.I is vastly improved, with players running into position and dealing intelligently with the ball. A player will trap a ball if it comes to them, or chest the ball to their feet, or leap over a sliding tackle and regain control over the ball. Players will run onto the ball, spring the offside trap intelligently, and call for passes when they're in the clear. It's not completely perfect as I've seen an opposition goal keeper kick the ball as my player was running past, and my player stopped the ball and scored. There are also the errant passes that go straight instead of to the side, but these feel far less frequent than other soccer games of the past.

The ball and the players have a real physical presence, as in past years and other games, but usually this hasn't been implemented that well, with the ball bouncing off players at wrong angles and generally not feeling right. This time though, FIFA 09 feels almost perfect. Balls will die in open space, creating opportunities for faster pace men on your team and if you get a strong player running with the ball they'll athletically jostle for the ball, knocking a running player off their line and allowing you to tackle without resorting to a slide and invariably a free kick (or a dreaded card).

Speaking of free kicks, FIFA 09 is far more forgiving with play ons, with the Referee allowing play to continue. Once the ball goes out of play then cards are given, which can seem a little silly, but it's better than the game stopping and starting. It's still harsh with the Offside rule, giving it in situations that no linesman or ref ever could in real life, but it works both ways and has saved me as many times as hurt me.

As always, FIFA is packed with features. Manager mode is still here, and whilst it's marginally better than last year and still relatively easy to use and understand, it still is not as deep as PES' offering. With the copious number of teams and leagues to choose from it's a great long term game play option, especially if you begin in the lower leagues. Some people have issues with the A.I controlled teams not trading players in and out, but to me that's a minor gripe. Similarly Tournament mode has had some small tweaks, but feels as solid as last year. Some criticism last year were directed at the mode for not being realistic enough in terms of dates and calendars – I wouldn't know if that has been fixed, as again, I'm not that much of a "real life” soccer nut nor that nit picking to care too much.

The Be-A-Pro mode returns, and this time around gets the most love. Offering you the choice to create your own player, his position, and play through four seasons from reserves to major, all whilst improving the player. It's another deep and interesting addition to the FIFA series and one that commands attention. I made a player for Adelaide United in the A-League, and it was so satisfying whomping the ball into the net against Melbourne Victory, and then being called up for the reserves match to play for Australia against Slovenia. This year the real-time feedback given on where you are meant to be is more direct and helpful, but it's still difficult to play the back line well.

Where Be A Pro mode really shines though is online. You can now play 10 on 10 in the BAP online, and with up to 10 people playing in a set position during a match, it's probably the closest you'll get to play the beautiful game for real. There is no lack of people playing, so you can always pick up a match. It's a rush to nominate for the best positions, but the old adage is true – every player has their part to play. Sure, sometimes it feels like playing with a bunch of abusive under 5 year olds who'll run off the field as soon as the ice-cream man drives past, but with a serious bunch of people the matches are just as intense as a real league game. Furthermore lag hasn't been a problem in any of the games I've played, a considerable feat seeing as I had people from the UK, Canada, Australia and Spain in my games.

To aid in playing as a team on online games, FIFA introduces a Club mode, which is analogous to Clans. You have a bunch of people in the club, and these people can arrange matches against other clubs. On top of the online leagues and ranked matches, there is now almost as many options in Live as in single player, a real impressive feat.

One thing that really impressed me this year is the Achievements. Usually soccer games give you achievements for winning this league or that derby or completing the modes. In FIFA 09 they're based on what you do in the actual matches, and this in turn helps you become a better player. For example, there's an achievement for scoring a goal from a bicycle kick, and I've decided I want to get it, so I've been trying to perfect the bicycle kick. It's helping me learn and play the game better by playing more "percentage soccer” by working my way into better crossing positions rather than just trying to blast my way through the middle of the field on your own.

I've already mentioned the fluid player animation, and the good looks don't stop there. The stadiums look amazing, and player likenesses are almost spot on to their real-life counter parts. The BAP player creator is robust and you can create good renditions of yourself, but they didn't include a Tiger Woods import a photo option for your player which is a little disappointing. Also disappointing are the menus – they've been standardised across all EA sports games over the last few years and work a bit like the Xbox menu blades, but I'm still not sold on the whole idea because as the amount of content in the games has increased, they're gradually becoming more cluttered.

Sound wise the game is equally impressive, with the thud off the ball sounding spot on, and crowds chanting your clubs' name as you play, spurring you on. The commentary by Andy Gray and Martin Tyler can sometimes they fall behind the play and become a bit repetitive, but that's the nature of sports commentary really and just about every single sports game ever made has yet to nail this part of the game perfectly.